Skip to content

Cockpit Build - FS9 or FSX ?

Started by stephenbalmer, April 29, 2013, 11:02:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

stephenbalmer

Hello guys,

I am in a real turmoil again on which software to use as the basis of my 737 cockpit build. I will be using Prosim and FSUIPC among others to provide the actual interactive layer, but for visuals and flight model, I cannot decide.

I was going to use FSX but then had some advice that FS9 was just as good for this type of thing, was more stable, less resource hungry and easier to hack for visuals without panel interruptions. Then once settled on FS9 as the way forward, I was then advised on the superiority of FSX and the greater raft of high quality add-ons such as airfields etc, as well as FSX now being capable of being eaten up by the sorts of hardware we run today etc, etc.

Which way are you guys going and which would you guide me to, and why?

Many thanks,

Steve

fsaviator

I was a hard-core FS9 guy... until I used FSX.

Bite the bullet and go to FSX.  At the end of the day FSX does a much better job with whatever resources you have available, and the graphics are so much better.  My 2cents
Warren "FSAviator"
http://www.B737NG-Sim.com  |  https://www.facebook.com/fsaviator/
P3D45/ Prosim737 2/ ACE Dual-linked Yokes/ RevSim Proline TQ and Dual-linked Rudders/ CPFlight MCP PRO3 and EFIS'; MIP737ICS_FULL and SIDE737; Forward and Aft Overheads; Pedestal/ FDS MIP

stephenbalmer

Thanks fsaviator, I believe one of the main challenges in using FSX is the outside views and the hit on CPU in generating. Can you tell me a little about your sim setup and te views that you have got setup?

My ultimate plan is to have projectors on a curved screen though as an nterim, i will use 5 lcd screens in wrap-around setup. I am thinking of using triple head to go unit for 3 screens but am still a little stumped on how to do far left and far right screens.

Thanks for any help or advice!

Steve

stephenbalmer

....surely someone else must have some opinions on this?

Steve

DaveC


XOrionFE

I agree.  X-Plane is the way to go.  However, you will only get a wide front view with a single computer and TH2go or surround video cards.   You need multiple computers to do a wraparound view with X-Plane.  No undocking of windows, etc..

At night X-plane is superior to FS hands down.   Daytime against FSX with addons such as Orbx and Real Environment is a tough call.   

FS9? ..... Don't bother unless you have older hardware in which case probably the only way to go.

My .02

stephenbalmer

Thanks very much DaveC and XOrionFE, very interesting perepsctive and one that I have really not considered until now.

I must confess that my researches had held me on the MS side of the fence, though not excluding anything.

Can you tell me a little about how this would work - what are the equivalents of FSUIPC, Prosim, etc, etc or are they universal across products? Are there any hardware considerations specific the XPlane that I would need to rethink?

Thanks again,

Steve

fsaviator

If you are in the position to be able to start with multiple systems then I would go with X-Plane from the beginning.  If not, then out of necessity you will need FS to get the multiple views.

I am running three projectors through a Triple Head 2 Go, projecting 180 degrees, on a curved screen.  I use Prosim and three total computers to run my simpit, with a fourth (laptop) as the instructor station.

I am running FSX, and get 15-20 FPS on a the ground at an airport with about 80% AI and airport vehicles.  Once Airborne I have not dropped below 25 FPS that I know of, even with REX.  My system specs are below.

I was a die-hard FS9'er until I switched to FSX.  Truthfully though, when ready, I will be upgrading to X-Plane 10.  I just can't be bothered right now as the demo won't run on my laptop for whatever reason and I don't have time to deal with it.

Hope that helps.

Warren
Warren "FSAviator"
http://www.B737NG-Sim.com  |  https://www.facebook.com/fsaviator/
P3D45/ Prosim737 2/ ACE Dual-linked Yokes/ RevSim Proline TQ and Dual-linked Rudders/ CPFlight MCP PRO3 and EFIS'; MIP737ICS_FULL and SIDE737; Forward and Aft Overheads; Pedestal/ FDS MIP

stephenbalmer

Thanks Warren,

Very interesting. Are you saying then that XPlane 10 is altogether a better sim software but requires multiple PC's for multiple outside views?

Does Prosim work with XPlane?

Thanks,

Steve

fsaviator

X-Plane appears to be developing into a better sim.  The key term there is "developing", which is what FS lacks.

Scott (XOrionFE) has a pretty good thread here about his build since going over to XP10.  The only difference is he's using a few "small" LCDs as opposed to projectors now.  That means he doesn't need the warping software and screen.  Regardless, the key thing on that is the multiple views.  Yes, XP10 requires a system (meaning an instance of XPlane) per view.

Prosim does not natively support Xplane at this time but Sim-A (FDS) does.
Warren "FSAviator"
http://www.B737NG-Sim.com  |  https://www.facebook.com/fsaviator/
P3D45/ Prosim737 2/ ACE Dual-linked Yokes/ RevSim Proline TQ and Dual-linked Rudders/ CPFlight MCP PRO3 and EFIS'; MIP737ICS_FULL and SIDE737; Forward and Aft Overheads; Pedestal/ FDS MIP